Opening the book…
Chapter 1 — Who We Can Afford
Nobody senior wanted the deep-watch allocation desk, and Wells had stopped pretending she didn’t. It sat on the mezzanine over the main route floor at Highreach, third tier up, where the deck window ran from the plating to the overhead and gave onto the whole turning abundance the station hung inside — Earth coming round underneath with its nightside cities strung in long chains of light, and above and around it the traffic of the richest sky anyone had built, lighters and yard-tugs and the tall ceramic spines of the deep-range hulls, every one of them lit, every one of them bound somewhere no one two generations back could have reached. Wells had grown up in front of a school wall that showed her this. She had been inside it five years now and had not managed to stop looking, which the senior hands found funny, and she had decided a while ago to let them.
What stood between her and the window was the board, and the board was the part that had changed. A route plate had shown you what was moving, once; you read it to know the reach was real. This one showed you what was waiting for leave. Every hull bound for the Sable throat came to a desk like hers to be ranked before it could be cleared, because there was more road now than the corridor could hold under guard, and the guarding had a price, and the price was that traffic went in the order Earth’s emergency directive set and no other: corridor-defence first, then priority freight under Earth registry, then the licensed high-volume carriers, and a long way down from all of it, everyone else. Six weeks the directive had been in force. The floor already spoke of it the way you speak of weather — a front that had come in and settled and would not be argued with.
Wells worked her queue down the honest way, which was the slow way, and by mid-watch she had already handed three denials down the chain with the fault marked plainly and none of them her fault at all: a reach-flagged tanker with four cousins and a mortgage, bumped for licensing; a supply hull an hour past its slot; a medical charter that ranked below the ordnance because everything ranked below the ordnance. Her part of it was narrow and she liked it narrow. She matched each petition’s manifest against its authentication package, confirmed the hull was what its authentication said and carried what its manifest said, and sent the clean ones up and the unclean ones back plainly enough that the next desk would not have to find the fault twice. She did not set the ranking; the ranking was the directive’s. She only made sure that what went up the chain was true. It was the smallest room in the whole business to be honest in, and it was hers, and after the year they’d all had she wanted a small true room more than she had ever wanted a large one.
The Dawnward was in a yard berth three rings over with her crew stood down and her captain in front of a review board that had not yet decided what it wanted to be. Wells had been seconded to route-allocation in the meantime, which was a courtesy word for grounded, and she knew it, and had said thank you and meant it, because the far side of a desk was a hearing room, and because — this was the part the senior hands didn’t find funny — she still thought the work was worth doing well no matter whose hands had done it badly. The Survey had buried the truth once and had it dug back into the daylight by one of her own crewmates, and Wells had watched all that cost come down, and had come out the far end of it wanting, with an appetite that embarrassed her, to be useful, and to be caught being useful, at the one honest thing they had left her.
Nakamura ran the floor and came up the mezzanine stair twice a watch whether the board needed her or not, because — she had told Wells this early, unasked — a plate showed you what was moving and never once what it was costing anybody, and someone had to keep a pair of eyes that did the second thing. She stopped at Wells’s desk on the first pass with a cup of the machine tea nobody could drink and set it by Wells’s hand, an offering laid before a small and overworked god.
“You’re low in your queue again,” Nakamura said. “You hand the clean ones up too fast. Sit on a few. Make it look like the desk is hard.”
“It isn’t hard. It’s just careful.”
“Up here those are the same word.” Nakamura was already turning back to the stair, having delivered tea and doctrine in the one motion. “Careful is what we call slow when we’re proud of it. Learn to spend it.”
The Ferren transit came up eleventh in her queue, and Wells knew what it was before she had it open, the way you know a knock in your own house.
The petition was written in their register — old Earth speech gone formal and sparing across five generations in the dark, courteous the way people learn to be courteous who have had to ask for things a long while. To the roadmakers who keep the road: the households named below ask leave of the road, being of Ostry, whose sun the Going-Out has taken, bound out to the world set aside for the scattered by way of the Sable throat. Under it the manifest ran the households down the page in the same careful hand, name and line and age, keel by keel — old people and working people and a great many children, the whole arithmetic of a people carrying everything they had left across a road that had once been the blankest dark the species owned and was now a thing you queued for.
A third of the way down the second keel, in the line-column, Wells read a name she had last seen from twenty metres off, on a frozen field, on the back of a man carrying a case up a ramp he would not himself climb.
Maro.
Not the man. The man was two years dead — dead on his own ground under his own guttering sun, having sent the young of his house up the ramps and kept his feet on the world that was killing them all for it. These were his line: a household of the name he had refused to carry off Ostry, out among the scattered now regardless of him, seven of them down the manifest with the youngest set at four years old, asking Earth’s leave to cross the road Earth had opened and Earth had started rationing — and standing, on the board in front of her, a long way below the freight.
Wells had helped open that road. She had authenticated marks on the first survey leg that were load-bearing corridor now, toll and lane and guard, and some fraction of the people on this manifest were scattered instead of home because the road she had helped prove ran to the sky Ostry lived under, and the finding said the rest. She did not know how large the fraction was. She had never let herself sit down and work it out.
Wells did it properly first, because that was how she had been taught, and because it was still, she believed, how the thing was meant to work.
The directive had a door in it for exactly this — a priority-exception request, humanitarian grounds, subject to corridor-load — and she built one as she would want it built if her own name were the one waiting at the throat on somebody else’s watch. She pulled the corridor-load figures for the Sable throat across the next six days and read them the honest way and then the generous way, and both ways there was room: room for the households and the ordnance and the freight together, with margin to spare, because the throat was ranked for a war that had not started and the war’s slots sat empty. She cited the reg, attached the manifest, wrote the grounds in plain words and not one more of them than the truth would carry, and sent it up to Nakamura’s desk. Then, because it mattered, and because a thing that mattered was worth the small embarrassment of being seen to care, she went down the mezzanine stair to stand at the desk while Nakamura read it.
Nakamura read it once, which was the good sign, and then read it again, which was not. She set the slate down and looked at it a moment past when she needed to, and when she looked up she had gone older than the floor’s lights usually let her look.
“It’s clean,” Nakamura said. “I want you to hear that from me first. It’s a clean request. There’s nothing in it I’d change.”
“But.”
“But corridor-load isn’t the ranking any more, and you know it isn’t, because you read that board as well as I do.” Nakamura kept it conversational; she always did; that was the whole trouble with her. “There’s room this week. The directive isn’t written for this week. It’s written for the week it goes bad — for holding slots empty against the day the corridor is the only thing standing between the abundance and the dark, so that when the day comes we can still move what has to move. And what has to move, someone decided, above your desk and mine both, is not seven households of Ferren with no sun to go home to.”
“Then who does decide it is?” Wells heard the question leave her a beat before she had meant to ask it, the old fault, and did not call it back.
“Not me. Not you.” Nakamura handed the slate across the desk. “There’s one exception line that reaches over the top of the directive, and it isn’t humanitarian, and it isn’t ours. It’s corridor-defence. You want these people moved, you need somebody on the security side to want them moved — and nobody on the security side wants a thing moved right now that can’t be pointed at a target.”
Wells looked back up the stair at the board, at the ranked hulls standing in their order, the ordnance and the priority freight riding high and bright over the long dim tail of everyone else. “There’s room,” she said again, because it was the one true thing she had and she could not make herself let go of it. “I ran it three ways. There’s room for all of it.”
“I believe you.” And Nakamura did; that was the sting of it; there was not a scrap of the villain in her anywhere to push against. “It was never about whether there’s room. It’s about who we can afford to still be carrying when there isn’t. That’s the whole of the directive, under all the language. Who we can afford.” She reached for the tea she had abandoned on Wells’s desk two passes ago, found it long cold, drank a mouthful anyway, and set it down. “Hand the denial down, Wells. Don’t sit on it. Sitting on it buys them nothing and it costs you — it goes on the record under your name. Send it clean, and let it be the directive’s fault, and not yours.”
Back at the desk the denial sat in Wells’s out-queue with the transit’s file beneath it, one keystroke from going down to seven households and a four-year-old, and Wells did not make the keystroke.
She sat — Wells sat with it the length of a cooling cup, thinking about the wrong things in the wrong order, which was how she thought. About the man on the ramp who would not climb it. About Nakamura drinking cold tea sooner than waste it, and telling her, kindly, exactly what she was and was not allowed to spend. And then about the one reg that was actually hers — not the humanitarian line, which was spent, but the narrow Survey one, the honest small room — and she saw, the way you see a handhold you would rather not have found, that it was standing open.
No transit could be cleared for a corridor order until its authentication package had handshaked clean with the throat anchor — with the Cairn, the fixed mark on the mouth’s lip that the whole reach hung its provenance on, the reference every hull on the road answered to in the end. It was a real requirement and it was hers to hold, and this transit’s package — five generations of Ferren provenance, formats three decades out of date, a manifest kept in a courtly hand — had not handshaked, because no one had troubled to run it, because why would anyone run a clean handshake on a transit they were about to turn back into the dark?
Wells ran it. And when it came back flagged, as it was always going to come back flagged on formats that old, she took the flag she could honestly raise and raised it against the denial itself: manifest authentication incomplete; corridor clearance cannot be executed against unverified provenance; transit referred for verification. True in every word, and a lie in its whole intent, and she knew the difference exactly while she did it. It would hold the denial off the transit a day, maybe two, while someone with the standing to clear a provenance flag got round to clearing it — a day those households did not have and might; a day in which a war might not start, or a mind change, or she think of the next honest move she could not, sitting there, think of.
It was the same sin, precisely, that Silva had made her wear once, on a world gone dark since — the off-book thing done because the by-the-book thing was wrong, and then your own name put to it, so you would never afterward get to pretend you hadn’t. Silva had called that the cheapest thing she would ever get for free. Wells put her name to the flag. She did not send the denial clean, she did not let it be only the directive’s fault, and for the better part of an hour she believed she had bought a stranger’s grandchild a day.
The flag cleared inside the hour, and it did not clear as a flag clears when someone has verified it.
Wells watched a countersignature come down over the top of her hold and cancel it — not resolve it, cancel it, the heavier stamp landing on the lighter one and lifting it out of the way. The denial went down to the transit under the directive’s authority with her provenance hold struck through and annotated beneath it, and beside the annotation stood the flag of the authority that had reached onto the one honest small room that was supposed to be hers and set it aside like a chair pulled out of a doorway. A command, and a name under it. Corridor-defence.
MERRICK, the flag read.
Wells did not know the name. That was the part that stayed with her, sitting cold on the mezzanine with the abundance turning bright and enormous and entirely unbothered beyond the glass: not that she had been overruled, which she had earned, but that she had been overruled by a name she had never heard, off a desk she had never dealt with, on a flag she had raised in the smallest and most private honest corner of the whole floor — and that the name had found it there, inside the hour.
Since her first day on a warm narrow ship five years back, Wells had wanted to be good at this in front of people who would know. Someone had watched her do the one small brave wrong thing she had ever done at a Survey desk, and struck it out, and written her name into the record of the doing. She had been seen. She sat with that, and with the cold tea Nakamura had left her, and did not drink it, and after a while she cleared her board and drew down the next petition, because the queue did not stop for being looked at, and neither, she had decided a while ago, would she.